Tesla Model S

NMRam

Still Here Because I'm Not There
Joined
Sep 25, 2009
Posts
8,487
Reaction score
58
Location
Ft Sumner, NM
My biggest issue with straight electric vehicles (besides cost and questionable battery/maint costs) is that we drive such long distances to get anywhere in NM that the battery range just doesn't cut it on them. I could be swayed to a hybrid at some point in the future, but don't think I would ever go full electric until the technology evolves A LOT!
 

azmidget91

Please select another custom user title.
Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Posts
792
Reaction score
0
Location
Maricopa, AZ
as an engineering student who is going to GM tomorrow to talk to them about a job, i am not a huge fan on the current electric cars. a guy i know who converted his bmw z4 calculates his cost to recharge and compares to current gas prices and says he only saves about $500 a year on fuel cost (btw cost him $20,000 to convert it...). i feel that going electric at this point is not the answer, and wont be untill you can charge the batter in a similar amount of time that it takes to fill your gas tank. untill then the public will not like electric cars. i think that if they can come up with a way to rapidly charge the batteries then it would be a good option.
 

RedRider

LIFETIME SUPPORTER
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2009
Posts
11,995
Reaction score
0
Location
2 miles from 49ers new stadium
as an engineering student who is going to GM tomorrow to talk to them about a job, i am not a huge fan on the current electric cars. a guy i know who converted his bmw z4 calculates his cost to recharge and compares to current gas prices and says he only saves about $500 a year on fuel cost (btw cost him $20,000 to convert it...). i feel that going electric at this point is not the answer, and wont be untill you can charge the batter in a similar amount of time that it takes to fill your gas tank. untill then the public will not like electric cars. i think that if they can come up with a way to rapidly charge the batteries then it would be a good option.

I know a guy in Florida converted an old car to electric. Could this be the same guy?
 

OldCracker29

I've been knocked down drug out and left for dead
Joined
May 26, 2009
Posts
80,093
Reaction score
965
Location
NE Ohio
as an engineering student who is going to GM tomorrow to talk to them about a job, i am not a huge fan on the current electric cars. a guy i know who converted his bmw z4 calculates his cost to recharge and compares to current gas prices and says he only saves about $500 a year on fuel cost (btw cost him $20,000 to convert it...). i feel that going electric at this point is not the answer, and wont be untill you can charge the batter in a similar amount of time that it takes to fill your gas tank. untill then the public will not like electric cars. i think that if they can come up with a way to rapidly charge the batteries then it would be a good option.

I don't understand why they can't have some kind of system involving the rotation of the wheels. Something similar to those giant windmills. :dunno:
 

azmidget91

Please select another custom user title.
Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Posts
792
Reaction score
0
Location
Maricopa, AZ
as an engineering student who is going to GM tomorrow to talk to them about a job, i am not a huge fan on the current electric cars. a guy i know who converted his bmw z4 calculates his cost to recharge and compares to current gas prices and says he only saves about $500 a year on fuel cost (btw cost him $20,000 to convert it...). i feel that going electric at this point is not the answer, and wont be untill you can charge the batter in a similar amount of time that it takes to fill your gas tank. untill then the public will not like electric cars. i think that if they can come up with a way to rapidly charge the batteries then it would be a good option.

I know a guy in Florida converted an old car to electric. Could this be the same guy?

Nope, tihs was the guys first conversion, there are ton of people out there who have done the swap
 

NCSU_05_FX4

Underwater Engineer
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2009
Posts
1,534
Reaction score
0
Location
Raleigh, NC
I know a guy in Florida converted an old car to electric. Could this be the same guy?

His name wasn't Terry was it?

Batteries still kill the environment, and you still have to charge them using coal-fired plants.

I wonder how much your electric bill will go up charging that thing every night? :dunno:

These are the big reasons I'm not buying into the electric car just yet. So you plug it into your house at night (I'd rather not run an extension cord from my house to my parking spot but that's just me) and it'll suck power, and I'm guessing it'll be at a pretty decent rate. So you're paying an increased power bill which cuts into those fuel savings you're getting.

On top of that, the majority of our power comes from coal plants, so really what you're driving is a coal powered car. Of course they'd never advertise it that way!

I don't understand why they can't have some kind of system involving the rotation of the wheels. Something similar to those giant windmills. :dunno:

They kinda do with the regenerative braking. Problem with just attaching something to the wheels is it would take more energy to spin the wheel than you could collect from it (unless you are slowing down), so it's a net loss.

If you are braking you can capture some of the energy and store it, or if you were coasting downhill you could probably generate some power from that. Railroad locomotives use Dynamic Braking, where instead of using their electric motors to turn the wheels, they'll basically switch the direction of the generators and instead of supplying power to the wheels, they can generate power (and heat) which slows down the wheels and helps control the speed of a train when going downhill.
 

cRiPpLe_rOoStEr

We don't ride to provide a good story for the rice
Joined
Jan 21, 2011
Posts
4,072
Reaction score
3
Location
South America
My biggest issue with straight electric vehicles (besides cost and questionable battery/maint costs) is that we drive such long distances to get anywhere in NM that the battery range just doesn't cut it on them. I could be swayed to a hybrid at some point in the future, but don't think I would ever go full electric until the technology evolves A LOT!

I also could consider to get a hybrid instead of a full electric at least until the technology evolve enough. There are already some interesting hybrid systems...
 

cRiPpLe_rOoStEr

We don't ride to provide a good story for the rice
Joined
Jan 21, 2011
Posts
4,072
Reaction score
3
Location
South America
i feel that going electric at this point is not the answer, and wont be untill you can charge the batter in a similar amount of time that it takes to fill your gas tank. untill then the public will not like electric cars. i think that if they can come up with a way to rapidly charge the batteries then it would be a good option.

Not just the same amount of time, but also the same range should be retained in an electric car.
 

Staff online

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
28,836
Posts
1,109,352
Members
4,800
Latest member
SpeakerMan
Back
Top